Skip to main content
Energy Review
Supplier comparison

Octopus Energy vs Utilita Energy (November 2026)

Overview

Our verdict
★ Winner: Octopus Energy

Octopus Energy is the better all-round pick, with stronger customer ratings and service scores, though Utilita answers phones faster and replies to more emails within two days.

Key takeaways

Octopus Energy is the stronger all-round choice on current evidence, mainly because customers and independent assessors rate it more highly. It scores 4.8 on Trustpilot against 4.3 for Utilita, 3.67 out of 5 from Citizens Advice against Utilita's 2.53, and 74% in the Which? total score against 68%. Its Flexible Octopus variable tariff is also £8 a year cheaper than Utilita's Smart Energy tariff, although that works out at only about £1 a month. Utilita answers the phone faster and replies to more emails within two days. Because it is built around Smart Pay As You Go, it may still suit households who value quick contact or want to top up as they go.

•Higher Trustpilot rating (4.8 vs 4.3) and Citizens Advice score (3.67 vs 2.53)
•Flexible Octopus costs £1,664 a year, £8 less than Utilita's Smart Energy at £1,672
•Better rated apps on both the App Store and Google Play
Trustpilot
Octopus Energy
4.8
911,202 reviews
Utilita Energy
4.3
113,129 reviews
Citizens Advice rank
Octopus Energy
#5
Utilita Energy
#15
Cheapest variable
Octopus Energy
£1,664
/year
Utilita Energy
£1,672
/year
iOS app
Octopus Energy
4.8
Utilita Energy
4.4

About Octopus Energy and Utilita Energy

Who are Octopus Energy?

Octopus Energy is the household energy brand of Octopus Energy Group. In June 2025, the group described itself as a global clean energy tech business working in 32 countries, backed by pension funds, investors and energy companies. Which? groups Octopus with Ovo as relative newcomers that now sit alongside the traditional big energy firms.

Octopus has built its business on technology it developed in-house. Its Kraken platform helps run its smart tariffs, and the group also licenses Kraken to other energy companies, including EDF, E.ON and Origin Energy. The wider group also invests in, builds and manages renewable energy projects. Octopus presents itself as a company trying to move homes towards electric heating, electric cars and smarter use of power, rather than only selling gas and electricity.

Products & services

Fixed and flexible home tariffs
Flexible Octopus, the standard variable tariff, alongside fixed-price deals for households who want set prices for a period.
Smart import tariffs
Tariffs for homes with a compatible smart meter. These include wholesale-linked Agile Octopus and Octopus Tracker, Octopus Go and Intelligent Octopus Go for electric cars, Cosy Octopus for heat pumps, and Octopus Flux for solar and battery homes. Octopus fits a smart meter free if needed, subject to engineer availability and signal.
Export tariffs
Outgoing Octopus, plus Agile and Prime versions, pays for electricity your home sends back to the grid from solar panels, battery storage or other generation.
Solar panel and battery installation
Octopus designs and installs solar systems of 2 to 36 panels depending on the equipment, with battery options including 5kWh Enphase and Fox EVO batteries and the 13.5kWh Tesla Powerwall 3. Prices start at £6,663 for two panels with no battery, and its most popular 12-panel system with a 10kWh battery costs £11,115 (2026 prices). You pay a £500 non-refundable deposit, then pay in full after installation or monthly with a fixed-term loan.
Heat pump installation
Octopus installs its own Cosy heat pumps. It says data from installed systems shows typical seasonal performance of about 3.6, meaning 3 to 4 kWh of heat for each kWh of electricity, and its heat pumps are independently tested by the Building Research Establishment.
Electric car leasing
Lease a brand-new or approved used electric car directly from Octopus for a monthly payment that includes servicing, maintenance and repairs. Many cars also come with a home charger.
Electric car leasing through your employer
If your employer offers the scheme, one monthly cost covers the car, insurance, servicing, charging credit and breakdown cover. Octopus says this can save up to 40% compared with personal leasing and describes it as a tax-efficient way to go electric. It is offered through thousands of UK employers.
Home EV charger installation
Smart, app-controlled home chargers designed to work with Octopus tariffs, fitted by engineers backed by Which? Trusted Trader.
Electroverse public charging
One app and one card giving access to more than 1.2 million public chargers across the UK and Europe on a single bill, with no subscription. Octopus EV drivers get extra discounts.
Octoplus rewards
Octopus's rewards programme for customers, offering freebies and offers ranging from weekly drinks to cinema tickets.

Awards & recognition

✓Which? Recommended Provider — Which?, 2026 — ninth year in a row
✓Best Customer Service — Uswitch Energy Awards, 2025
✓Most Awarded UK Energy Supplier Overall — August Recognition Ltd, 2024 — based on customer service awards won in the calendar year
✓The Sunday Times Best Places to Work — The Sunday Times, 2025 list — workplace recognition
✓Best Company to Work For — UK Company Culture Awards, 2025 — workplace recognition

Who are Utilita Energy?

Utilita has offered energy to households since 2003 and calls itself the home of Smart Pay As You Go. Prepayment is at the centre of the business: customers top up and keep track of their balance, and Utilita describes its aim as smarter, fairer energy.

Utilita also puts weight on face-to-face help. It describes itself as the only supplier on your high street, with Energy Hubs where customers can get in-person support, alongside its app and prize draws for customers.

Products & services

Smart Pay As You Go energy
Prepayment energy that you top up and track. Utilita says none of its Pay As You Go tariffs has a standing charge, so you pay only for the energy you use.
My Utilita app
Lets Pay As You Go customers check their balance, top up in seconds and see where their energy is going. Utilita says the app has won Uswitch awards four times.
Energy Hubs
High-street centres where Utilita customers can get in-person support.
Utilita Extra and Utilita Jackpot
Weekly Utilita Extra prize draws for things such as gadgets, gift cards, getaways, gig experiences at Utilita Arena and football tickets, plus the chance to win up to £5,000 through Utilita Jackpot just for being a customer.
Home solar and battery storage
Utilita gives example savings for a 16-panel solar system with its 5.32kWh battery storage. Actual savings depend on the equipment, your usage, where you live and how much shade your roof gets.
Affiliate
Thinking about switching to Octopus?

Use our referral link, and we'll both get £50 credit once your switch is complete.

Existing customer? Find out how you can benefit too. T&Cs apply (only one switching offer per household)

Tariffs and pricing

Octopus Energy
CHEAPEST
VARIABLE
Flexible Octopus
£1,664/year
No fixed term · Variable rates can change
Best for: maximum flexibility
FIXED 18M
Octopus 18M Fixed October 2026 v7
£1,848/year
18-month term · Exit fee £150
Best for: price certainty
FIXED 12M
Octopus 12M Fixed October 2026 v8
£1,899/year
12-month term · Exit fee £100
Best for: a shorter fixed commitment
Utilita Energy
VARIABLE
Smart Energy
£1,672/year
No fixed term · Variable rates can change
Eligibility

Requires a smart meter

Best for: maximum flexibility

The lowest annual estimate shown for Octopus Energy is Flexible Octopus, a variable tariff at £1,664 a year with a £0 exit fee. Utilita's priced tariff, Smart Energy, is also variable and also has a £0 exit fee, but costs £1,672 a year. That makes Octopus £8 a year cheaper, or about £1 a month, which is a small gap for most households. Because both tariffs are variable, their rates can change, and all the estimates here assume you pay by monthly Direct Debit.

If you want a fixed price, the cheapest Octopus deal shown is the Octopus 18M Fixed October 2026 v7 at £1,848 a year. It holds prices for 18 months, but you would pay a £150 exit fee if you left early. The Octopus 12M Fixed October 2026 v8 costs £1,899 a year, about £51 more, and in return asks for a shorter 12-month commitment with a lower £100 exit fee. Either way, fixing with Octopus currently means paying more for set prices: the 18-month deal costs about £184 a year more than Flexible Octopus.

There is no Utilita fixed tariff among the deals priced here, so this comparison can only set Utilita's variable tariff against Octopus's variable and fixed options.

Octopus Energy vs Utilita Energy — Tariffs and pricing
MetricOctopus EnergyUtilita Energy
Cheapest tariff exit fee£0£0

Octopus Energy and Utilita Energy: Tariff Options

Octopus Energy tariffs

Most Octopus households start with the choice between Flexible Octopus, the standard variable tariff that Octopus calls a protected tariff, and a fixed deal. Octopus 12M Fixed October 2026 v8 and Octopus 18M Fixed October 2026 v7 hold your prices for 12 and 18 months. The 12-month edition is the shorter commitment and costs less to leave early, while the 18-month edition gives longer protection if you expect to stay put.[1]

The smart tariffs need a smart meter Octopus can read every half hour, usually a SMETS2 or Secure SMETS1 meter. New customers start on a standard tariff while the switch and meter connection go through, which generally takes about 14 days. If you don't have a smart meter, Octopus will fit one free, depending on engineer and stock availability and the signal where you live. Octopus runs these tariffs as a beta programme and warns that smart meter or third-party problems can stop things working first time. Once you join a smart tariff, you can't move to another smart tariff for 30 days, and if you go back to a standard tariff you can't rejoin a smart tariff for 30 days.[2]

Octopus Tracker and Agile Octopus pass wholesale price changes straight through to you. Tracker sets one unit rate each day, while Agile sets a different price for every half hour. Both have a price ceiling called Price Cap Protect, but Octopus says Tracker's ceiling is far above Ofgem's price cap, and anyone who can't afford prices that high is probably better off on a protected tariff such as Flexible Octopus. Tracker's formula and standing charge stay the same for 12 months, and leaving during that term means waiting nine months before you can rejoin. Octopus Shape Shifters takes a simpler approach, with cheaper electricity for nearly all of the day if you avoid a few peak hours.[3][4]

For electric car owners, Octopus Go gives the whole home cheaper electricity from 00:30 to 05:30 and works with any EV, with or without a home charger. Intelligent Octopus Go goes further: you link a supported car or charger in the Octopus app, and Octopus schedules your charging and gives the whole home six cheaper hours from 23:30 to 05:30. In return, Octopus controls when the car charges and you must keep the device linked. Cosy Octopus is built for heat pumps, electric boilers and electric radiators, with three cheaper periods a day and a 16:00 to 19:00 peak. Octopus's terms say Go, Intelligent Octopus Go and Cosy Octopus come in both variable and fixed versions, so your quote will show which version you're offered and any term.[5][6][7]

Homes with solar panels and a battery can use Octopus Flux, which pairs cheap early-morning charging with a higher-value evening peak for both import and export, though you set the battery schedule yourself. Moving to Flux or Outgoing Octopus means giving up Feed-in Tariff export payments, but your Feed-in Tariff generation payments carry on. Outgoing pays for electricity sent to the grid from solar panels, batteries or other generation, and its Agile and Prime versions each run for 12 months with a locked-in rate formula. Charge Pack is an add-on rather than a tariff: Octopus takes control of an approved home battery and pays extra during sessions it chooses.

Flexible Octopus
No exit fee
Best forHouseholds wanting a flexible variable tariff
Octopus 18M Fixed October 2026 v7
18-month contract · Exit fee £150
Best forHouseholds comparing fixed-rate deals
Octopus 12M Fixed October 2026 v8
12-month contract · Exit fee £100
Best forHouseholds comparing fixed-rate deals
Octopus Tracker
Unit rate changes every day with wholesale prices, using a formula and standing charge fixed for 12 months · Price Cap Protect sets a daily ceiling far above Ofgem's price cap, so prices can rise sharply
Eligibility

Octopus customers only (new customers switch to Flexible Octopus first) with a working smart meter Octopus can read half-hourly: SMETS2 or some SMETS1, including Secure SMETS1. A meter running in Economy 7 mode must be reset to a single register for electricity, which can take about 4 weeks. Leave during the 12-month term and you must wait 9 months to rejoin; leave at the end of the term without renewing and there is no wait.

Best forSmart meter households who can handle daily price changes and want lower bills when wholesale prices fall
Agile Octopus
A different price every half hour, tied to wholesale costs and usually published between 4pm and 10pm for the next day · Prices rise when more power is used than generated; spikes usually last 30 minutes to an hour · Price Cap Protect puts a ceiling on any half-hour price
Eligibility

Must be an Octopus customer; new customers start on a standard tariff first; Needs a compatible smart meter sending half-hourly readings before the switch completes.

Best forHouseholds who can move electricity use away from peak times
Octopus Shape Shifters
Cheaper electricity for nearly all of the day · Higher prices during a few peak hours
Eligibility

Octopus household customers.

Best forHouseholds that can move some electricity use away from a few peak hours
Cosy Octopus
Three cheaper Cosy periods every day: 04:00–07:00, 13:00–16:00 and 22:00–00:00 · Higher peak rate from 16:00 to 19:00; times stay the same in summer time whatever the in-home display shows
Eligibility

A heat pump (air or ground source), electric boiler or electric radiators, installed and working; other low-carbon heating systems are at Octopus's discretion; Your home must be supplied by Octopus; new customers start on an interim tariff; A SMETS2 or Secure SMETS1 smart meter Octopus can take half-hourly readings from.

Best forHomes heated by a heat pump or electric heating that can run heating in the cheaper periods
Octopus Flux
Cheaper import from 02:00 to 05:00 to top up your battery · Peak period 16:00–19:00 applies to both import and export, the time to discharge and export
Eligibility

Solar panels and a home battery installed and working, not necessarily fitted by Octopus; Already on an Octopus import tariff and Outgoing Octopus export; new customers switch to Flexible Octopus and Outgoing first; Smart meter for import and export with half-hourly readings, plus an export MPAN, which Octopus can apply for; Give Octopus the MCS certificate for your solar system and your G98/G99 certificate from the network operator; Feed-in Tariff export payments stop for good and are replaced by Flux export payments; generation payments carry on. If another supplier pays your FiT export, you tell them to stop; You set your battery's charging and discharging schedule yourself.

Best forHomes with solar panels and a battery that can store cheap power and export in the evening
Outgoing Octopus
Your smart meter measures export in half-hour blocks, shown separately from what you use · Export earnings can put your bill in credit, which Octopus will refund if you ask · Applying doesn't change your import tariff
Eligibility

Must be an Octopus customer; new customers start on an interim tariff; Smart meter that sends half-hourly export data (almost all SMETS2 and most SMETS1); Works with any standard import tariff, such as Flexible Octopus, but only certain smart tariffs; Needs an export MPAN from the network operator (usually 1 to 4 weeks) and normally your MCS certificate, DNO notification form and the DNO's response; Feed-in Tariff export payments stop (opt out of deemed export), but generation payments carry on; If your FiT payments started in the last 12 months, you can't switch yet; Best for homes with renewable generation, but you don't have to generate power to benefit; a home battery can export too.

Best forHomes with solar panels, battery storage or other generation that want to be paid for power sent to the grid

Utilita Energy tariffs

Smart Energy is the Utilita tariff in our price comparison. It is a variable tariff, so its rates can change. Utilita calls itself the home of Smart Pay As You Go and says none of its Pay As You Go tariffs include a standing charge, so you pay only for the energy you use. Customers check their balance and top up in the My Utilita app.

The choice between these suppliers is largely about how you want to run your account. Octopus's specialist tariffs reward homes with an electric car, heat pump, solar panels or battery that can move their use to cheaper times. Utilita is built for households who want to manage spending by topping up as they go, with in-person help at its Energy Hubs. Utilita says switching usually takes no more than five working days.

Smart Energy
No exit fee · Smart meter required
Eligibility

Requires a smart meter

Best forHouseholds wanting a flexible variable tariff

Customer reviews

★Trustpilot
Octopus Energy4.8 / 5
Utilita Energy4.3 / 5
⚖Citizens Advice
Octopus Energy#5
Utilita Energy#15
✓Which?
Octopus Energy74 %
Utilita Energy68 %

Octopus Energy has a Trustpilot rating of 4.8 from 911,202 reviews, while Utilita has 4.3 from 113,129 reviews, so both ratings rest on a very high volume of reviews. The gap is clearest at the ends of the scale. 90% of Octopus reviews are five-star against 73% for Utilita, while 15% of Utilita reviews are one-star compared with 3% for Octopus. Overall, 17% of Utilita reviews are negative, against 4% for Octopus.

Octopus reviewers often praise knowledgeable, polite staff on the phone and an easy-to-use online account, and say changes to tariffs or new services are handled quickly. The main complaints are about booking appointments, repeated estimated bills and slow progress on complex meter problems. A smaller group say promised follow-up calls never came or that account changes were made wrongly.

Utilita reviewers often describe support staff as kind and patient, and value calm help during stressful situations. Criticism centres on long phone waits, trouble getting quick help with urgent problems, delayed engineer visits, unexpected billing errors and poor communication during house moves. Both suppliers respond to most negative reviews: Utilita replies to 99%, typically within 24 hours, while Octopus replies to 97%, typically within a week.

Which? gives Octopus a total score of 74% and Utilita 68%. In the Which? customer survey, Octopus scores 4 out of 5 for overall customer service, ease of contacting and clarity of statements, while Utilita scores 2 out of 5 on each. The separate Which? supplier assessment gives both suppliers 10 out of 10 for help for those who need it, and Utilita scores 10 out of 10 for smart meters, against 5 for Octopus.

Apps and online accounts

App Store
Octopus Energy4.8 · 268,000 ratings
Utilita Energy4.4 · 27,000 ratings
Google Play
Octopus Energy4.3 · 47,585 ratings
Utilita Energy4.1 · 61,592 ratings

Both suppliers' apps list 1,000,000+ installs on Google Play, so each is widely used. Octopus is better rated on both platforms. On the App Store, it scores 4.8 from 268,000 ratings against 4.4 from 27,000 for Utilita, and on Google Play it scores 4.3 from 47,585 ratings against 4.1 from 61,592. Its Google Play net-positive share is 69.2%, compared with 58.1% for Utilita.

Utilita says its My Utilita app lets Pay As You Go customers check their balance, top up in seconds and see where their energy is going. Because these features are aimed at prepayment customers, they matter most if you plan to top up rather than pay by Direct Debit.

Both apps are updated regularly, with three iOS updates each in the last 90 days. Octopus's latest release came out seven days ago on both platforms, and Utilita's 27 days ago. Not every user is happy, though: one Octopus iPhone user reported repeated gaps in the app's usage data and a gas reading that looked far too high.

Service and support

Citizens Advice rank
Octopus Energy
#5
Utilita Energy
#15
Citizens Advice score
Octopus Energy
3.67
out of 5
Utilita Energy
2.53
out of 5
Emails ≤2 days
Octopus Energy
86.4%
Utilita Energy
99.7%
Avg call wait
Octopus Energy
1.2 min
Utilita Energy
5 sec
ChannelOctopus EnergyUtilita Energy
Routine phone enquiries

Average response: 1.2 min (April to June 2026)

Hours: Monday 9am-5pm, Tuesday 9am-5pm, Wednesday 9am-5pm, Thursday 9am-5pm, Friday 9am-4pm

Average response: 5 sec (April to June 2026)

Email

Replies: 86.4% within 2 days (April to June 2026)

Hours: 7 days/week

Replies: 99.7% within 2 days (April to June 2026)

Webchat
Not reported

Average response: 37 sec (April to June 2026)

Hours: Available

WhatsApp
Not reported

Replies: Average 21 min (April to June 2026)

For April to June 2026, Citizens Advice gives Octopus 3.67 out of 5 and ranks it 5th, while Utilita scores 2.53 and ranks 15th, a clear gap in the overall service score. Octopus's bills are also more often based on actual meter readings rather than estimates. For Octopus, 96.33% of smart meter bills and 93.99% of traditional meter bills used actual readings, compared with 87.44% and 75.3% for Utilita.

Utilita does better on contact speed. Its average call centre wait time was 5 seconds, against 1 minute 9 seconds for Octopus, and it answered 99.7% of emails within two days, compared with 86.4% for Octopus. Utilita's average webchat response was 37 seconds and its average WhatsApp response was 20 minutes 52 seconds, although there are no matching Octopus figures for these channels, so they can't be compared. Some Utilita reviewers still describe long phone waits, so individual experiences vary.

Utilita also has a higher share of working smart meters, at 96.36% against 91% for Octopus. For routine enquiries, Octopus's phone lines are open Monday to Thursday 9am to 5pm and Friday 9am to 4pm, and it says email support is available seven days a week.

Billing and meteringOctopus Energy — April to June 2026Utilita Energy — April to June 2026
Smart meters working correctly91%96.36%
Bills based on readings — smart meters96.33%87.44%
Bills based on readings — traditional meters93.99%75.3%

Complaints and how they are handled

Per 100k customer accounts
Octopus Energy
476
Q2 2026
Utilita Energy
946
Q2 2026
External complaints per 10k
Octopus Energy
21.4
Citizens Advice — April to June 2026
Utilita Energy
95.7
Citizens Advice — April to June 2026
Resolved same/next day
Octopus Energy
43%
Q2 2026
Utilita Energy
66%
Q2 2026
Resolved ≤8 weeks
Octopus Energy
80%
Q2 2026
Utilita Energy
93%
Q2 2026

Both suppliers report their own complaint figures for Q2 2026, so these can be compared directly. In that quarter, Octopus Energy received 476 complaints per 100,000 customer accounts. Utilita Energy received 946, almost twice as many. These figures count complaints made to the supplier, not the number of people who complained. One customer may complain more than once, and one household can hold more than one account.

Utilita dealt with complaints faster in the same quarter. It resolved 66% of complaints on the same or next working day and 93% within 8 weeks. Octopus resolved 43% on the same or next working day and 80% within 8 weeks. These figures only show how quickly complaints were closed. They do not show whether customers were happy with the outcome. Utilita had more complaints for its number of accounts, but it closed a larger share of them quickly.

Citizens Advice figures for April to June 2026 tell a similar story. They count complaints that customers took to advice bodies and the Energy Ombudsman, not complaints made to the supplier. Octopus had 21.4 of these complaints per 10,000 customers. Utilita had 95.7, more than four times as many. This measure uses a different base from the supplier figures, so it should not be set against the per 100,000 account rates above. It can suggest how often customers felt they needed outside help.

Neither supplier says which period its main complaint themes cover, so they may not match the Q2 2026 figures. Utilita gives the share of complaints for each theme but no detail or response. Octopus lists its themes in order without shares, along with what it says it has done and plans to do.

Octopus Energy — complaint themes
Customer service
Response
Done: Octopus says it set up a staff training programme, the Operations Academy for Ongoing Excellence, and has grown its teams so more people can answer customers. Ongoing: it says it is expanding training, with refresher courses each month for all staff, and giving more staff the chance to build their skills and become team experts.
Billing and meter readings (not linked to meter type)
Response
Done: Octopus says it has added more tailored detail to statement emails, given fuller answers to common questions, and tightened its back billing rules so customers are not charged for energy used more than 12 months ago. Ongoing: it says it is reviewing its billing system for products such as Intelligent Octopus and Fan Club, making it easier to send meter readings correctly, and improving staff training on complex billing queries.
Smart meter billing and readings
Response
Done: Octopus says its Smart Tariff bills now show more clearly where costs come from. Its system now fetches missing usage data when a bill has not gone out on time. It has also started regular staff training on Smart Tariff billing problems. Ongoing: it says it is improving how its system creates Smart Tariff bills automatically, training staff further and getting better at finding and fixing billing failures so statements arrive on time.
Payment issues
Response
Done: Octopus says it regularly reviews Direct Debits so payments match energy use and works with customers to keep monthly payments affordable. It expanded its Octo Assist Fund, setting aside £40m for winter support, and offers an online financial support form. Online accounts show a projected balance six months ahead, and it has an in-house team of qualified social workers to help vulnerable customers. Ongoing: it says it is working with other organisations to make affordability checks simpler, including checks on benefit entitlement. It gives free heated throws to customers who need them and offers tailored help such as standing charge holidays or reduced payments. It also keeps reviewing the support it gives staff who handle payment problems.
Smart meter installation and faults
Response
Done: Octopus says its number of working smart meters grew by over 1.3 million in the last 12 months. It reports that over 97% of installations succeed on the appointment date, with automatic retries meant to sort out the rest within 24 hours. In the last year it says it replaced over 350,000 smart meters with new ones and updated the software on nearly 4 million. It began switching to 4G communications hubs from Q4 2025, is testing Wi-Fi based options and offers all customers the Octopus Home Mini. Planned: it says it will replace more meters in 2026, give frontline staff instructions to set up meters remotely and keep growing its in-house installation team. It is also working with Tesla on new services and tariffs for electric vehicle drivers.
Utilita Energy — complaint themes
Customer service
42%
Payment issues
21%
Smart prepayment meters and installation
12%
Smart meter billing and readings
8%
Prepayment debt and disconnection
4%

Green energy: Octopus Energy and Utilita Energy compared

Octopus Energy
86%Renewable
Apr 2024–Mar 2025
Renewables86.4%
Nuclear13.6%
Other0%
Gas and Coal0%
Utilita Energy
Dated fuel mix unavailable

Octopus Energy's green energy

For the year from 1 April 2024 to 31 March 2025, Octopus's fuel mix disclosure shows the electricity it supplied to customers was 86.4% renewable and 13.6% nuclear, with no gas or coal. So none of that supply came from fossil fuels, but it was not all renewable: nuclear power is low-carbon rather than renewable. The figure is an average across all Octopus customers over the year, so it does not tell you what was reaching your home at any particular hour.

Octopus says it mainly buys electricity from renewable sources such as wind, solar and hydro. It buys renewable electricity directly from more than 700 UK generators through Power Purchase Agreements (PPAs), which are contracts to buy power from a named generator. Its FAQ explains that it buys some renewable electricity to match what customers use and covers the rest through these PPAs, some with independent generators and some with projects in the portfolio of UK renewable producers it operates.

Community energy is part of this buying. Octopus says it buys green power from one-third of the community energy sector through more than 250 PPAs. In these projects, local people own and run the generation, and profits go back into local charities or environmental projects.

Two named tariffs carry a specific '100% renewable' promise. On Agile Octopus and Octopus Flux, Octopus matches every MWh of electricity used on the tariff with a Renewable Energy Guarantee of Origin (REGO) from British renewable generation. A REGO is a certificate showing that a unit of renewable electricity was produced. The certificates record an equivalent amount of British renewable electricity generation, but they do not mean renewable power reaches your home every half hour. These promises belong to those named tariffs, not to every Octopus deal.

Octopus has also started owning wind turbines itself. It says it owns two turbines in Yorkshire and South Wales and has adopted two more, in Lincolnshire and Yorkshire, from wind farms it operates. Through the Octopus Fan Club, communities living closest to these turbines can get their power up to 50% cheaper when the turbines are working hardest.

Larger-scale generation sits with Octopus Energy Generation, part of Octopus Energy Group, which backs, builds and manages renewable energy projects. In May 2026 it reported £8.5bn of assets under management, 5.7 GW of capacity across its portfolio, and enough output from the assets it manages to power 2.8 million homes a year. These are managed investments within the wider group, separate from the household supplier, and they are not each tied to a particular Octopus tariff.

Utilita Energy's green energy

We don't show a fuel mix for Utilita in the chart above, so this comparison can't say what share of its electricity came from renewable or nuclear sources. If the make-up of your electricity matters to you, Utilita's annual fuel mix disclosure is the figure to compare with Octopus's 2024–25 result.

What Utilita does promote is generating power at home. Its homepage gives an example for a large-usage home, using roughly 5,700 kWh a year, of saving up to £916 a year with a 16-panel solar system and its 5.32kWh battery storage, plus up to a further £359 a year from exporting spare power at 12p per kWh. Utilita says the figures follow the standard method of the Microgeneration Certification Scheme (MCS) and assume 54% of the solar power is used in the home when a battery is fitted. Real savings depend on the equipment chosen, your usage, where you live and how much shade falls on your roof.

Our verdict

Which should you choose?
If you care most aboutChoose
The cheapest variable tariff shownOctopus Energy
Higher app ratings on iPhone and AndroidOctopus Energy
Our verdict
★ Winner: Octopus Energy

Octopus Energy is the better all-round pick, with stronger customer ratings and service scores, though Utilita answers phones faster and replies to more emails within two days.

Octopus Energy comes out ahead as a company, mainly because its customers rate it more highly. It scores better on Trustpilot, with 90% of reviews five-star, and leads on the Citizens Advice score (3.67 vs 2.53) and the Which? total score (74% vs 68%). Which? customers gave it 4 out of 5 for customer service, against 2 out of 5 for Utilita. Its bills are more often based on actual meter readings, and its apps are better rated on both iPhone and Android. On price, its Flexible Octopus tariff is also £8 a year cheaper than Utilita's Smart Energy.

The main drawback with Octopus is contact speed. Its average phone wait of just over a minute and its email reply rate both trail Utilita, and its listed routine phone hours cover weekdays only. Some reviewers also report repeated estimated bills and slow progress on meter problems.

Utilita may suit households who want Smart Pay As You Go, with balance checks and top-ups in the My Utilita app. It may also suit people who would use its high-street Energy Hubs for face-to-face help, or who care most about getting through quickly. However, its weaker customer survey scores and 15% one-star share on Trustpilot point to more mixed customer experiences than at Octopus.

Octopus EnergyWinner
✓Pros
  • Trustpilot rating of 4.8 from 911,202 reviews, with 90% five-star
  • Citizens Advice score of 3.67 and a Which? total score of 74%
  • More bills based on actual meter readings (96.33% smart, 93.99% traditional)
  • Better rated apps on the App Store (4.8) and Google Play (4.3)
  • Flexible Octopus costs £1,664 a year with a £0 exit fee, £8 less than Utilita's Smart Energy
×Cons
  • Average call centre wait of 1 minute 9 seconds, against 5 seconds at Utilita
  • 86.4% of emails answered within two days, against 99.7% at Utilita
  • Cheapest fixed deal shown has an 18-month term and a £150 exit fee
  • Reviewers mention estimated bills and slow fixes for complex meter problems
  • 5 out of 10 for smart meters in the Which? supplier assessment
Utilita Energy
✓Pros
  • 5-second average call centre wait and 99.7% of emails answered within two days
  • 96.36% of smart meters working and 10 out of 10 for smart meters from Which?
  • Built around Smart Pay As You Go, with balance checks and top-ups in the My Utilita app
  • Replies to 99% of negative Trustpilot reviews, typically within 24 hours
  • Smart Energy variable tariff has a £0 exit fee
×Cons
  • 15% of Trustpilot reviews are one-star, against 3% for Octopus
  • Citizens Advice score of 2.53, ranked 15th
  • 2 out of 5 in the Which? customer survey for customer service, ease of contacting and clarity of statements
  • Fewer bills based on actual readings, especially for traditional meters (75.3%)
  • No fixed tariff among the deals priced here
Affiliate
Thinking about switching to Octopus?

Use our referral link, and we'll both get £50 credit once your switch is complete.

Existing customer? Find out how you can benefit too. T&Cs apply (only one switching offer per household)

Frequently asked questions

Will I pay an exit fee if I leave?

Not on the cheapest tariffs shown. Flexible Octopus and Utilita's Smart Energy both have a £0 exit fee. Octopus's fixed deals do charge you to leave early: £150 on the Octopus 18M Fixed October 2026 v7 and £100 on the Octopus 12M Fixed October 2026 v8.

How long do Octopus's fixed deals last?

The two Octopus fixed deals priced here last 18 and 12 months. The 18-month deal costs £1,848 a year with a £150 exit fee. The 12-month deal costs £1,899 a year with a £100 exit fee. Both cost more than the Flexible Octopus variable tariff at £1,664 a year.

Can I pay as I go with Utilita?

Utilita describes itself as the home of Smart Pay As You Go. It says the My Utilita app lets Pay As You Go customers check their balance, top up and see where their energy is going. The Smart Energy price shown here, £1,672 a year, is based on paying by monthly Direct Debit, so a prepayment quote may differ.

When can I phone Octopus Energy?

Octopus's routine phone lines are open Monday to Thursday 9am to 5pm and Friday 9am to 4pm. It says email support is available seven days a week. Between April and June 2026, its average call centre wait time was 1 minute 9 seconds.

How quickly does Utilita respond to customers?

Between April and June 2026, Utilita's average call centre wait time was 5 seconds, and it answered 99.7% of emails within two days. Its average webchat response was 37 seconds and its average WhatsApp response was 20 minutes 52 seconds. Some Trustpilot reviewers still describe long phone waits.

Which supplier is more likely to bill me on actual meter readings?

Octopus. Between April and June 2026, 96.33% of its smart meter bills and 93.99% of its traditional meter bills were based on actual readings. The figures for Utilita were 87.44% and 75.3%.

Do Octopus and Utilita help customers who need extra support?

Both score 10 out of 10 for help for those who need it in the Which? supplier assessment. In the Which? customer survey, customers rated Octopus 4 out of 5 for overall customer service and Utilita 2 out of 5.

Where does Octopus get its electricity from?

Octopus's fuel mix disclosure for 1 April 2024 to 31 March 2025 shows the electricity it supplied was 86.4% renewable and 13.6% nuclear, with no gas or coal. This is an average across all its customers for the year.

What changed this month

This month, Octopus Energy's iOS sampled positive reviews rose from 0 to 1, Octopus Energy's iOS sampled negative reviews rose from 0 to 2, and Utilita Energy's iOS sampled negative reviews rose from 1 to 2. There were 16 other data changes this month — see the full changelog below for details.

Data changes this month (26)

Related comparisons

Related reviews

Related guides

Rob Gibbs

Written by

Rob Gibbs

Hi, I'm Rob, and I run Energy-Review.co.uk. I initially started this project in 2018 when I was looking to switch energy suppliers and found there wasn't a website that provided simple, data-backed reviews on all the suppliers available. Since then, I have spent a lot of time (too much, some may say!) looking at all publicly available data about each supplier and writing reviews using this information. These reviews are updated as regularly as possible, and any data is backed up by a source where necessary. I have also started writing guides on various energy-related topics, which hopefully you will find useful. If you find any issues, please use our contact form to let us know.

Comments

Leave a comment

We publish your name and comment. Your email is never published and is used only if we need to reply. We also store a one-way hashed form of your IP address to detect spam. See our privacy policy.