Skip to main content
Energy Review
Supplier comparison

EDF Energy vs Good Energy (November 2026)

Overview

Our verdict
★ Winner: Good Energy

Good Energy has the stronger service record and app ratings, while EDF Energy's cheapest priced tariff costs £143 a year less.

Key takeaways

Good Energy has the stronger service record, while EDF Energy has the lower price shown. Citizens Advice scores Good Energy 3.68 out of 5, against 2.96 for EDF, and Which? gives it a total score of 69%, against 58% for EDF. Good Energy's callers also waited about half as long on average. On price, EDF's Simply Tracker Jan28 is estimated at £1,622 a year, which is £143 less than Good Energy's Standard Variable at £1,766, although the EDF tracker carries a £100 exit fee. Because both suppliers have a 4.8 Trustpilot rating, households focused mainly on price may still prefer EDF.

•Higher independent service scores: 3.68 vs 2.96 from Citizens Advice and a Which? total score of 69% vs 58%
•Shorter average call centre wait from April to June 2026: 1 minute 27 seconds vs 2 minutes 47 seconds
•Higher Google Play rating: 4.6 vs 4.3, with 89.5% net-positive ratings vs 72.5%
Trustpilot
EDF Energy
4.8
268,502 reviews
Good Energy
4.8
15,137 reviews
Citizens Advice rank
EDF Energy
#10
Good Energy
#4
Lowest tracker/variable
EDF Energy
£1,622
/year
Good Energy
£1,766
/year
iOS app
EDF Energy
4.6
Good Energy
4.7

About EDF Energy and Good Energy

Who are EDF Energy?

EDF Energy describes itself as Britain's biggest generator of zero carbon electricity. It runs power stations as well as supplying homes, and says it is building wind, nuclear and solar supply in Britain to reduce reliance on energy imports and help prevent future price rises. Its customers' electricity comes from its own UK power stations, the wholesale energy market and other independent generators.

Nuclear power is a large part of the business, and EDF trains apprentices at stations such as Heysham 2. The household supplier also sits within a wider group, and EDF counts people working for EDF Trading, EDF power solutions, Dalkia, EDF Heat Pumps, Contact Solar and Pod as EDF staff.

EDF says it gave advice and support to over 300,000 households struggling with energy bills last year, including rebates through the Warm Home Discount scheme. Pay-as-you-go customers at risk of being unable to top up can get extra credit and a pause on debt repayments, and its most vulnerable customers can get energy-efficient fridges and washing machines.

Products & services

Standard, fixed and tracker tariffs
Standard (Variable) follows the Ofgem price cap and has no end date. Simply Fixed deals hold unit rates and standing charges for a set term. Simply Tracker follows the price cap with a discount on the daily standing charge.
Electric vehicle tariffs
GoElectric gives cheaper electricity in a standard 11pm to 6am window. A Smart Charging bolt-on adds extra off-peak hours and an annual bill credit if you let EDF manage your charging. Pod Plug & Power pairs a two-year fixed-price tariff with a Pod Point home charger.
Heat pump tariff
Heat Pump Tracker gives six hours of discounted electricity a day, from 4am to 7am and 1pm to 4pm, without a peak rate. It is open to homes whose heat pump was fitted by any installer.
Smart time-of-use tariffs
FreePhase Static and FreePhase Dynamic split the day into red, amber and green price bands. Customers are told a day ahead about free electricity periods when EDF can offer them.
Solar panels and batteries
You can buy any combination of solar panels and batteries from EDF, installed by Contact Solar. Buying gives access to exclusive solar import and export tariffs.
Export tariffs
These pay you for surplus electricity you send back to the grid. Some suit homes that already have panels, while others are only for people buying new solar or battery systems through EDF.
Flextras rewards
This is EDF's rewards programme. If you refer a friend and they join, you both get £50 off your energy bill. Members can also earn free electricity hours through Weekend Saver, get Bonus Hours that last 12 months and get a tastecard membership.
Power Perks
Customers on an EDF smart time-of-use tariff, such as an EV, solar or heat pump tariff, can use free electricity during events. EDF sends a text the day before each event.

Who are Good Energy?

Good Energy describes itself as one of the UK's first renewable energy companies, with more than 25 years in the business. The brand is a trading name of Good Energy Services Limited, a company registered in England and Wales with its registered office at Monkton Park in Chippenham, Wiltshire.

Its approach centres on renewable power from independent producers. Good Energy says it buys electricity directly from over 3,000 independent British generators, and it tries to match what customers use with renewable generation in the same half hour, rather than only balancing the books across a whole year. It is also the UK's only B Corp home energy supplier. B Corp is a certification for businesses that meet set standards on social and environmental performance, and the company presents it as a sign of its commitment to people and planet.

Products & services

Renewable electricity and greener gas tariffs
Variable and fixed supply tariffs for electricity only or dual fuel, plus smart time-of-use tariffs designed for EV drivers and homes with heat pumps. Electricity on all tariffs is matched with 100% renewable power, and gas comes with 10% biogas and Gold Standard carbon offsetting.
Solar panel and battery installation
Good Energy designs and installs SolarEdge optimised solar systems with panel-by-panel monitoring, and most solar-only systems are fitted in a single day. Batteries include Tesla Powerwall, Sig Energy and SolarEdge models from 5 to 13.5kWh. It is certified by MCS and NICEIC and is a Tesla Powerwall premium installer. Finance is available at 9.9% APR representative, subject to status and affordability.
Solar Care maintenance
Three Solar Care packages for solar owners: an annual service, a solar panel clean, or unlimited engineer call outs.
Solar export tariffs
Solar Savings pays for spare solar electricity sent to the grid. Households that install both solar panels and a battery with Good Energy can get Solar Savings Exclusive, with a rate fixed for 12 months once the term starts.
Heat pump installation through Installio
Air source heat pumps are installed across England by Good Energy's partner Installio, which handles the survey, design, installation and aftercare under its Warm Guarantee. Installio applies for the government's £7,500 Boiler Upgrade Scheme grant on your behalf where you are eligible. It cannot install in flats, maisonettes or apartments, and the outdoor unit needs space on flat ground.
EV charger installation
Home EV charger installation, offered alongside Good Energy's EV tariff for cheaper overnight charging.
Affiliate
Thinking about switching to Octopus?

Use our referral link, and we'll both get £50 credit once your switch is complete.

Existing customer? Find out how you can benefit too. T&Cs apply (only one switching offer per household)

Tariffs and pricing

EDF Energy
CHEAPEST
TRACKER
Simply Tracker Jan28
£1,622/year
Ends 31 January 2028 · Tracked rates can change · Exit fee £100
Best for: customers comfortable with tracked rates
FIXED 24M
Simply Fixed 2Yr Nov28v2
£1,948/year
24-month term · Exit fee £200
Best for: price certainty
FIXED 12M
Simply Fixed Nov27v2
£2,094/year
12-month term · Exit fee £100
Best for: a shorter fixed commitment
Good Energy
VARIABLE
Good Energy Standard Variable
£1,766/year
No fixed term · Variable rates can change
Best for: maximum flexibility
FIXED 18M
Good Energy 18m Fix Nov26
£1,887/year
18-month term · Exit fee £150
Eligibility

Requires a smart meter

Best for: price certainty

The lowest annual estimate shown for EDF Energy is Simply Tracker Jan28, a tracker tariff at £1,622 a year, while Good Energy's lowest is the Good Energy Standard Variable tariff at £1,766. That makes the EDF tracker £143 a year cheaper, or about £12 a month. The rates on both tariffs can change, but they are different products. The EDF tracker also has a £100 exit fee, while Good Energy's standard variable tariff has no exit fee.

EDF also prices its Standard (Variable) tariff at £1,672 a year with no exit fee, which is about £93 a year less than Good Energy's standard variable tariff. It may suit households who want EDF but would rather not pay to leave.

On fixed prices the order flips. Good Energy 18m Fix Nov26 costs £1,887 a year, fixes prices for 18 months and has a £150 exit fee. That is £60 a year less than EDF's Simply Fixed 2Yr Nov28v2 at £1,948, a 24-month deal with a £200 exit fee. EDF also prices a shorter Simply Fixed Nov27v2 at £2,094 for 12 months, with a £100 exit fee, so households choosing it pay more each year in return for a shorter commitment and a smaller charge for leaving early.

EDF Energy and Good Energy: tariff options

EDF Energy

Most homes choose between Standard (Variable), which follows the Ofgem price cap, can change every three months and has no end date, and Simply Fixed, which holds unit rates and standing charges for 12 or 24 months. The two-year deal gives longer certainty but carries a bigger exit fee than the one-year deal, so it suits households confident they will stay. Simply Tracker Jan28 also moves with the price cap each quarter, but EDF takes a discount off the daily standing charge for each fuel. Unlike Standard (Variable), it can carry an exit fee, and customers with a traditional prepayment meter need to move to smart pay as you go to get it.

GoElectric is a 12-month fixed tariff with cheaper electricity from 11pm to 6am that works with any EV and charger. Pod Plug & Power adds a Pod Point charger, with part of its cost paid upfront and the rest spread over a two-year fixed-price tariff. GoElectric customers can add the Smart Charging bolt-on, letting EDF control when the car charges in return for extra off-peak hours and an annual bill credit. It is open to existing domestic customers aged 18 or over in England, Scotland or Wales who own an eligible EV or home charge point, have a working half-hourly smart meter and use MyAccount and paperless billing. It can't be used alongside another flexibility scheme or charging schedule.[1][2]

Heat Pump Tracker follows the price cap but gives six discounted hours a day with no peak rate, for homes heated by an air source heat pump, whoever fitted it. FreePhase Static and FreePhase Dynamic suit homes that can move electricity use away from 4pm to 7pm. Static fixes the price of each band for the tariff, while Dynamic sets new prices a day ahead based on wholesale costs, so your bill depends more on when you use power. EDF says smart tariffs may suit you less if you use most of your electricity at peak times or can't easily change when you use it.

Empower Fixed Exclusive 12m and Export Exclusive 12m V3 are only for households that submit an enquiry and buy solar panels, a battery or both through EDF after 2 March 2026, with installation by Contact Solar. Export 12m V2 also suits homes that already generate their own power. All of these need you to buy your home electricity from EDF.

Simply Tracker Jan28
Exit fee £100
Best forHouseholds considering a tariff linked to market or price-cap movements
Standard (Variable)
No exit fee
Best forHouseholds wanting a flexible variable tariff
Simply Fixed 2Yr Nov28v2
24-month contract · Exit fee £200
Best forHouseholds comparing fixed-rate deals
Simply Fixed Nov27v2
12-month contract · Exit fee £100
Best forHouseholds comparing fixed-rate deals
GoElectric
Off-peak electricity every night from 11pm to 6am
Eligibility

You need an electric vehicle; A smart meter that keeps sending half-hourly readings, with half-hourly reads switched on. If it stops communicating, you move to the Standard Variable tariff; Pay by Direct Debit; EDF must be the only flexibility services provider for your EV and home

Best forEV drivers who charge at home overnight
Heat Pump Tracker
Discounted electricity from 4am to 7am and 1pm to 4pm, with no peak rate · Variable rates can change · Day rate and standing charge set at EDF's Standard rate in your region
Eligibility

An air source heat pump used to heat your home, from any installer; A smart meter that keeps sending half-hourly readings, with half-hourly reads switched on. If it stops communicating, you move to Standard (Variable); Pay by Direct Debit

Best forHomes heated by an air source heat pump
FreePhase Static
Red 4pm to 7pm, amber 6am to 4pm and 7pm to 11pm, green 11pm to 6am · Each band's price and the standing charge stay fixed for the tariff · Free electricity periods announced a day ahead when available, with no guaranteed number
Eligibility

An electricity smart meter that keeps sending half-hourly readings, with half-hourly reads switched on; Paperless bills and payment by Direct Debit; Agree to tariff messages by SMS or WhatsApp and sign up through the dedicated FreePhase process

Best forSmart meter homes that can avoid using power from 4pm to 7pm and want set prices
FreePhase Dynamic
Red, amber and green bands, with prices set a day ahead from wholesale costs · Unit rates are capped, and the standing charge can change each quarter for sign-ups from 10 March 2026 · Free electricity periods announced a day ahead when available, with no guaranteed number
Eligibility

An electricity smart meter that keeps sending half-hourly readings, with half-hourly reads switched on; Paperless bills, online account access and payment by Direct Debit; Agree to tariff messages by SMS or WhatsApp and sign up through the dedicated FreePhase process; Not on FreePhase Dynamic in the past 9 months

Best forFlexible smart meter homes comfortable with prices that change daily
Empower Fixed Exclusive 12m
Cheaper overnight rate from 1am to 4am and a higher peak rate from 4pm to 7pm · No standing charge for the 12-month term · Prices fixed for 12 months
Eligibility

This tariff is only for households who submit an enquiry and buy solar panels, a battery or both from EDF after 2 March 2026, with installation by Contact Solar. You must be an EDF customer: new customers join the Standard Variable tariff and MyAccount first. You also need a smart meter that keeps sending half-hourly readings, and you must pay by Direct Debit. You can't take the tariff again within 12 months unless you make another Contact Solar purchase, and it can only be used once per purchase.

Best forNew EDF solar or battery buyers who can charge a battery overnight
Export Exclusive 12m V3
Pays for surplus electricity you export · Starts once your export meter number (MPAN) is registered with EDF · Moves to Export Variable if you switch electricity supplier
Eligibility

This tariff is only for homes where a Contact Solar lead form, submitted on or after 2 March 2026, led to a new Contact Solar installation of solar panels, a battery or both. You need solar panels, with or without a battery, and no other generation technology. All panel and battery installations need an MCS or Flexi-Orb certificate and DNO letters, and total installed capacity must be 50kW or less. Your export smart meter must record half-hourly readings; if it can't send them automatically, you must give actual readings every quarter or sooner if asked. You must buy your home electricity from EDF as a residential customer and export only to EDF. You can't receive Feed-in Tariff export payments, or Smart Export Guarantee payments from another supplier. You can't take the tariff again within 12 months unless you make another Contact Solar purchase.

Best forHouseholds buying new solar panels or a battery through EDF
Export 12m V2
Pays for surplus electricity you export · Open to homes with existing generation as well as new EDF installations · Moves to Export Variable if you switch electricity supplier
Eligibility

Solar panels, onshore wind, hydro, anaerobic digestion or micro-CHP, up to 50kW in total, with an MCS certificate and a DNO letter; An export smart meter recording half-hourly readings. If it can't send them automatically, you give actual readings every quarter or sooner if asked; Buy your home electricity from EDF as a residential customer and export only to EDF. You can't receive Feed-in Tariff export payments, or Smart Export Guarantee payments from another supplier

Best forEDF electricity customers who already have solar panels or other small-scale generation

Good Energy

Good Energy's household tariffs come in variable, fixed and smart time-of-use forms, with electricity on all of them matched with 100% renewable power. Its supply tariffs are exempt from Ofgem's energy price cap because of the support they give renewable generation, and prices are set to reflect the cost of matching your use with electricity from independent British generators.

The Good Energy Standard Variable tariff works with smart and standard meters and has no exit fee, but its prices can change. Both can cover electricity only or dual fuel with greener gas.

The EV Tariff and Heat Pump Tariff are fixed supply tariffs with time-of-use pricing, where the price depends on the time of day. The EV Tariff is for EV owners only and is built for cheaper overnight charging, while the Heat Pump Tariff is designed for homes with heat pumps. Both need a smart meter, and switching takes a little longer because Good Energy has to set up your meter to send half-hourly readings.

For solar homes, Solar Savings is a variable export tariff that pays for electricity you send to the grid. If you install both solar panels and a battery with Good Energy, you can get Solar Savings Exclusive instead, with a rate fixed for 12 months once the term starts, after which you move to the standard export tariff.

Good Energy Standard Variable
No exit fee
Best forHouseholds wanting a flexible variable tariff
Good Energy 18m Fix Nov26
18-month contract · Exit fee £150 · Smart meter required
Eligibility

Requires a smart meter

Best forHouseholds comparing fixed-rate deals

Customer reviews

★Trustpilot
EDF Energy4.8 / 5
Good Energy4.8 / 5
⚖Citizens Advice
EDF Energy#10
Good Energy#4
✓Which?
EDF Energy58 %
Good Energy69 %

Both suppliers have a 4.8 Trustpilot rating, although EDF's is based on far more reviews: 268,502, against 15,137 for Good Energy. The spread of opinion is almost identical, with 84% of EDF reviews and 82% of Good Energy reviews rated five-star, while 6% and 5% respectively are one-star. Both reply to nearly every negative review, EDF typically within 24 hours and Good Energy typically within a week.

EDF reviewers often describe its phone staff as polite, patient and knowledgeable, and many value quick help with everyday account questions and contract changes. Most of the criticism is about communication. Some customers report long delays, trouble sorting out more complex problems, missed callbacks and staff not taking responsibility for mistakes.

Good Energy reviewers praise helpful, friendly staff, the chance to speak to real people and quick replies with clear advice free of jargon. Many say switching supplier and having solar panels fitted went smoothly. Complaints tend to focus on follow-up, with some saying technical queries took a long time to resolve, were missed for a while or were not chased up.

Which? gives Good Energy a total score of 69% and EDF 58%. In its customer survey, Good Energy customers rated it 3 out of 5 for both overall customer service and value for money, against 2 out of 5 from EDF customers. In Which?'s supplier assessment, EDF scored slightly higher for help for those who need it, with 9 out of 10 against 8 for Good Energy, while both scored 1 out of 5 for switching.

Mobile apps

App Store
EDF Energy4.6 · 193,000 ratings
Good Energy4.7 · 7,800 ratings
Google Play
EDF Energy4.3 · 52,739 ratings
Good Energy4.6 · 3,229 ratings

Good Energy's app is rated higher on both platforms, though the gap is much wider on Android. On the App Store the scores are close: Good Energy has 4.7 from 7,800 ratings and EDF has 4.6 from 193,000. On Google Play, Good Energy has 4.6 from 3,229 ratings against 4.3 from 52,739 for EDF, and its net-positive share there is 89.5%, against 72.5% for EDF. EDF's Android app is far more widely installed, with at least 1,000,000 installs compared with at least 10,000 for Good Energy.

Good Energy says customers can use its app and online account to submit meter readings, make payments, track their energy use and manage their account. One iPhone user praised its Insights feature, which shows usage and solar generation in kWh or pounds and compares it with the previous year, while another could not sign in after being asked to move to a new version of the app.

Reviews of EDF's iPhone app are mixed. One user said the current app is a big improvement on an older version that was slow and crashed often. Two others felt it had become harder to use than it once was, and one of them said it used to be a simple way to send meter readings and check bills.

Service and support

Citizens Advice rank
EDF Energy
#10
Good Energy
#4
Citizens Advice score
EDF Energy
2.96
out of 5
Good Energy
3.68
out of 5
Emails ≤2 days
EDF Energy
85.4%
Good Energy
89.5%
Avg call wait
EDF Energy
2.8 min
Good Energy
1.5 min
ChannelEDF EnergyGood Energy
Routine phone enquiries

Average response: 2.8 min (April to June 2026)

Average response: 1.5 min (April to June 2026)

Email

Replies: 85.4% within 2 days (April to June 2026)

Replies: 89.5% within 2 days (April to June 2026)

WhatsApp

Replies: 91% within 2 days (April to June 2026)

Not reported
SMS

Replies: 90.9% within 2 days (April to June 2026)

Not reported

For April to June 2026, Citizens Advice gives Good Energy 3.68 out of 5, placing it 4th in its table, while EDF Energy scores 2.96 and is placed 10th. The contact figures point the same way. Good Energy's average call centre wait time was 1 minute 27 seconds, against 2 minutes 47 seconds at EDF, and Good Energy answered 89.5% of emails within two days, compared with 85.4% for EDF.

EDF also has figures for text and WhatsApp messages, answering 90.9% and 91% respectively within two days. There are no matching figures for Good Energy, so these channels cannot be compared directly.

Meter and billing results are closer. In the same period, 92.67% of EDF's smart meters and 91.7% of Good Energy's were working. For smart meters, 97.6% of EDF bills and 96.09% of Good Energy bills were based on actual readings. The gap is wider for traditional meters, where 96.47% of Good Energy bills used actual readings against 90.75% at EDF, so households without a smart meter may get fewer estimated bills with Good Energy.

Billing and meteringEDF Energy — April to June 2026Good Energy — April to June 2026
Smart meters working correctly92.67%91.7%
Bills based on readings — smart meters97.6%96.09%
Bills based on readings — traditional meters90.75%96.47%

Complaints and performance

Per 100k customer accounts
EDF Energy
965
Q2 2026
Good Energy
683
Q2 2026
External complaints per 10k
EDF Energy
47.7
Citizens Advice — April to June 2026
Good Energy
10.9
Citizens Advice — April to June 2026
Resolved same/next day
EDF Energy
62%
Q2 2026
Good Energy
66%
Q2 2026
Resolved ≤8 weeks
EDF Energy
86%
Q2 2026
Good Energy
93%
Q2 2026

This section uses three kinds of complaint evidence: how many complaints each supplier says it received, how quickly it says it closed them, and how many complaints were taken to Citizens Advice and the Energy Ombudsman. These measure different things, so each is explained separately below.

Both suppliers reported their own complaint figures for Q2 2026, so these can be compared directly. In that quarter, EDF Energy received 965 complaints per 100,000 customer accounts, while Good Energy received 683 per 100,000 customer accounts. That means Good Energy reported fewer complaints for its size in the same quarter. These figures count complaints, not people, so they do not show what share of customers had a problem. One customer could make more than one complaint, and one person could hold more than one account.

On how quickly complaints were sorted out in Q2 2026, Good Energy resolved 66% by the end of the next working day, against 62% for EDF Energy. Within eight weeks, Good Energy had resolved 93% and EDF Energy 86%, so a larger share of EDF Energy's complaints took longer than eight weeks or were still open. These figures show speed only. They do not show whether customers were happy with the outcome.

The Citizens Advice figures cover complaints that customers took to advice bodies and the Energy Ombudsman, not complaints made directly to the supplier. For April to June 2026, EDF Energy had 47.7 of these complaints per 10,000 customers and Good Energy had 10.9 per 10,000 customers. Both figures cover the same period, so they can be compared directly: EDF Energy had a higher rate of complaints taken to advice bodies and the Energy Ombudsman. This measure uses a different base from the supplier-reported figures above, so the two sets of numbers should not be set against each other.

The main complaint themes below have no reporting period attached, so they may not cover the same quarter as the figures above. EDF Energy gives a share and a short description for each theme. Good Energy lists its themes in order but gives no shares or details, so the size of each problem cannot be compared between the two suppliers. Neither supplier gave details of what it has done or plans to do about these themes.

EDF Energy — complaint themes
Customer service
33%
General complaints about EDF Energy's customer service. This is a broad category, so it can include a range of different issues.
Billing and meter readings (not linked to meter type)
17%
Complaints about the layout of bills and the details shown on them, such as cancelled charges or payment dates. It also covers estimated readings, price increases and incorrect bills.
Payment issues
12%
Complaints about Direct Debit payments or prepayment credit.
Debt and debt-related disconnections (not prepayment)
9%
Complaints about unpaid energy charges at homes without a prepayment meter, including bill disputes, trouble paying debts back and how debts are recovered.
Smart meter installation, exchange and faults
7%
Problems with swapping meters, including appointment issues linked to the work at the property. It also covers smart meter faults and connection problems.
Good Energy — complaint themes
Billing
Feed in Tariff
Payments
Metering
Customer service

EDF Energy and Good Energy: green energy

EDF Energy

EDF's customers' electricity comes from its own UK power stations, the wholesale energy market and other independent generators, and EDF says it is a major supporter of independent renewable generators. Across its EDF Energy Customers Limited supply licence from 1 April 2025 to 31 March 2026, nuclear power was the largest source at 41.1%, followed by gas at 28.5%, renewables at 23%, coal at 5% and other sources at 2.4%. Nuclear produces no carbon dioxide when it generates power, but it is not renewable, which is why this low-carbon mix still has a modest renewable share.

EDF shows the UK average from the Department for Energy Security and Net Zero alongside its own: 48% renewable and 13.7% nuclear.

The source behind your electricity depends on your tariff. In the same period, products sold as renewable were backed by 100% renewable sources, and products sold as zero carbon or nuclear backed were backed by 100% nuclear power. All other products had a mix of 44% nuclear, 38.4% gas, 6.7% coal, 7.7% renewable and 3.2% other.

EDF says its heat pump tariffs are backed by zero carbon electricity it generates in the UK. In its disclosure, zero carbon products are backed by nuclear power, so this is a low-carbon promise rather than a renewable one. As with any supplier, customers receive electricity through the National Grid, not directly from the power stations behind a tariff.

Households that want to make their own power can buy solar panels and batteries through EDF, installed by Contact Solar, and EDF's export tariffs then pay for any surplus electricity sent back to the grid.

23%Renewable
Apr 2025–Mar 2026
Nuclear41.1%
Renewable23%
Other2.4%
Coal and Gas33.5%

Good Energy

Good Energy's electricity reaches homes through the National Grid, so the power in your sockets is a mix that includes fossil fuels. What changes is what the company buys for you: it matches all the power you use at home with renewable electricity from over 3,000 independent renewable generators, and it says this applies to all its tariffs. Rather than relying on buying renewable energy certificates to label power as green, it has contracts directly with these generators, chosen to give a mix that reflects when its customers use electricity.

It also aims to match supply and demand half hour by half hour, not just over a whole year. In 2026 it achieved an 87% half-hourly match between total customer demand and renewable generation in the same half hour, putting it first in the Matched Clean Power Index, an independent ranking of UK suppliers. Any gaps are matched over the year, so the 100% renewable promise is an annual match, with most of it timed to the same half hour.

For gas, Good Energy matches every customer's use over the year with at least 10% renewable biogas, which is gas made from organic material. It offsets all the carbon emissions from its gas customers, including those from producing and delivering the biogas, by investing in Gold Standard projects that improve access to renewable energy around the world. Its variable and fixed tariffs both come with this greener gas.

Separately from its supply, Good Energy helps households make their own power. It has completed over 7,000 solar and battery installations across England and pays solar homes for spare electricity they send to the grid.

Our verdict

Which should you choose?
If you care most aboutChoose
The lowest annual price shownEDF Energy
Higher independent customer service scoresGood Energy
Higher Android app ratingsGood Energy
Our verdict
★ Winner: Good Energy

Good Energy has the stronger service record and app ratings, while EDF Energy's cheapest priced tariff costs £143 a year less.

Good Energy is the better fit for households who put service first. It scores higher with Citizens Advice and Which?, its callers had shorter average phone waits and it answered more emails within two days. In the Which? survey, its customers rated its customer service 3 out of 5, against 2 for EDF, and its app is better rated on Android. Good Energy also matches the electricity on all its tariffs with renewable power bought from independent generators, which may matter to some households, whereas EDF's supply includes a large share of nuclear power.

EDF Energy is worth considering if the lowest price shown matters most. Its Simply Tracker Jan28 is £143 a year cheaper than Good Energy's cheapest priced tariff, although it carries a £100 exit fee, and EDF's Standard (Variable) is also cheaper than Good Energy's with no exit fee. Trustpilot reviewers rate both suppliers 4.8, and EDF scored higher in the Which? assessment of help for those who need it. For households who want the stronger service record, Good Energy is the better-supported pick.

EDF Energy
✓Pros
  • Simply Tracker Jan28 is £143 a year cheaper than Good Energy's cheapest priced tariff
  • Standard (Variable) costs £1,672 a year with no exit fee
  • 4.8 Trustpilot rating from 268,502 reviews, with replies typically within 24 hours
  • 9 out of 10 in the Which? supplier assessment for help for those who need it
×Cons
  • Citizens Advice score of 2.96, ranked 10th
  • Average call centre wait of 2 minutes 47 seconds
  • £100 exit fee on Simply Tracker Jan28 and £200 on the 24-month fixed deal
  • Which? customers rated it 2 out of 5 for customer service and value for money
  • Lower Google Play rating of 4.3
Good EnergyWinner
✓Pros
  • Citizens Advice score of 3.68, ranked 4th, and a Which? total score of 69%
  • Average call centre wait of 1 minute 27 seconds
  • Good Energy 18m Fix Nov26 is £60 a year cheaper than EDF's cheapest priced fixed deal
  • Standard Variable tariff has no exit fee
  • App rated 4.7 on the App Store and 4.6 on Google Play
×Cons
  • Cheapest priced tariff costs £143 a year more than EDF's
  • £150 exit fee on the 18-month fixed deal
  • Trustpilot replies typically take about a week
  • Some reviewers report slow follow-up on technical queries
Affiliate
Thinking about switching to Octopus?

Use our referral link, and we'll both get £50 credit once your switch is complete.

Existing customer? Find out how you can benefit too. T&Cs apply (only one switching offer per household)

Frequently asked questions

Do the cheapest tariffs have exit fees?

EDF's Simply Tracker Jan28, the lowest annual estimate shown at £1,622, has a £100 exit fee. Good Energy's Standard Variable, at £1,766, has no exit fee. EDF's Standard (Variable) tariff, at £1,672 a year, also has no exit fee.

How long are the fixed deals, and what does leaving early cost?

Good Energy 18m Fix Nov26 lasts 18 months, costs £1,887 a year and has a £150 exit fee. EDF's Simply Fixed 2Yr Nov28v2 lasts 24 months at £1,948 a year with a £200 exit fee. Its Simply Fixed Nov27v2 lasts 12 months at £2,094 a year with a £100 exit fee.

Which supplier is quicker to answer the phone?

Citizens Advice figures for April to June 2026 show an average call centre wait time of 1 minute 27 seconds at Good Energy. At EDF Energy the average wait was 2 minutes 47 seconds.

What can I do in the Good Energy app?

Good Energy says its app and online account let you submit meter readings, make one-off payments, track your energy use and manage your account. The app is rated 4.7 on the App Store and 4.6 on Google Play.

Which supplier is more likely to bill me from actual meter readings?

For April to June 2026, 97.6% of EDF smart meter bills and 96.09% of Good Energy smart meter bills were based on actual readings. For traditional meters the figures were 90.75% for EDF and 96.47% for Good Energy. The difference matters more if you do not have a smart meter.

Where does each supplier's electricity come from?

EDF's fuel mix covers EDF Energy Customers Limited from 1 April 2025 to 31 March 2026. Over that period its electricity was 41.1% nuclear, 28.5% gas, 23% renewable, 5% coal and 2.4% other. Good Energy says it matches the electricity on all its tariffs with 100% renewable power over the year. It buys this power directly from over 3,000 independent British generators.

Which supplier scores better for helping customers who need extra support?

In the Which? supplier assessment, EDF scored 9 out of 10 and Good Energy 8 out of 10 for help for those who need it. These scores rate each supplier's approach, not the help any one household will receive.

How do they respond to bad reviews on Trustpilot?

EDF replied to 99% of negative Trustpilot reviews, typically within 24 hours. Good Energy replied to 100%, typically within a week.

What changed this month

This month, EDF Energy's play store days since last update rose from 14 to 25, Good Energy's play store days since last update rose from 30 to 41, and Good Energy's iOS app days since last update rose from 29 to 39. There were 21 other data changes this month — see the full changelog below for details.

Data changes this month (27)

Related comparisons

Related reviews

Related guides

Rob Gibbs

Written by

Rob Gibbs

Hi, I'm Rob, and I run Energy-Review.co.uk. I initially started this project in 2018 when I was looking to switch energy suppliers and found there wasn't a website that provided simple, data-backed reviews on all the suppliers available. Since then, I have spent a lot of time (too much, some may say!) looking at all publicly available data about each supplier and writing reviews using this information. These reviews are updated as regularly as possible, and any data is backed up by a source where necessary. I have also started writing guides on various energy-related topics, which hopefully you will find useful. If you find any issues, please use our contact form to let us know.

Comments

Leave a comment

We publish your name and comment. Your email is never published and is used only if we need to reply. We also store a one-way hashed form of your IP address to detect spam. See our privacy policy.